In Thy Orisons

Great to see you again, meteor, with another great piece. My notes are going to be very pedantic and harsh just because, you know you're good, i know you're good, so we can do with the pleasantries and see if we can elevate great into perfect.

The opening paragraph could be better placed. He closes his eyes wile being somewhere, then walks through memory, then opens at a porch. I think the trick here would be to actually place frank somewhere first, then go into memory, then come out at the porch, so we get that juxtaposition. Especially since the savannah is introduced in the next paragraph, I feel you want to slightly more accodmating with your flow of images.

This goes for the savannah paragraph too. There is a sort of overloading of imagery here that doesn't fit with the voice imo. You could split the river smell sentence up into two sentences i think. The Cin Sat has the meaning of either she was sat or she actively sat, i.e, the sentence could be construed to mean that the narrator is witnessing cin sitting in that moment, but i dont think thats the case.

By the end of the first section, I guessing the story is about memory, about his wife having some degenrative disease.
"incongruous as a spaceship in the low room" - this line suffers from what the narrator just said, being written into a dead end. there's nothing incongruous about an iphone in a low room, but i imagine the room itself doesn't match the glass and steel, this would be a great place for you to actually place Frank.

"A laugh, sharp as a snapped pencil."

great line.

Frank stared at the wall. Someone--one of the nurses, maybe--had taped a color-coded chart there: Stages of Cognitive Decline. Stage 4 was circled in red. He had added a note in the margin, his handwriting shaky: Still knows her own name?

a bit on the nose, this.

"Trying to what? Rewrite the ending?"

this is something a writer would say, not what a daughter says to her estranged dad.

"Ink bloomed across his palm like a vein."

do veins really bloom? seems like a mixed metaphor here.

The ink had dried black against his lifeline.

great imagine

"Cuidado," the older one said, setting it on his desk. "Libros."

books are actually one of the least things a mover has to be careful with, and also one of the most annoying things. this line would almost be better as "carajo, libros"

sat in the pool of laptop light

pool here has too much a calming, positive connotation. can you make a description here do some emotional work too?

her hand on his wrist, counting his blood like rosary beads.

beautiful

The section with the journals was very compelling, a great shift in tone and voice and gives reald depth to the story, extending it in a natural way, not contrived. all great stuff.

two sharp buzzes that cut through the house like a saw.

i dont think you need these trite similies.

She straightened slowly, and in the lamplight Frank could see Cin in the set of her jaw, the way her nostrils flared slightly when angry.

beautiful, you capture his love for his daughter even in these moments of tension and despair

"I was terrified," he blurted out. "The book was selling, really selling, and suddenly everyone wanted to know Frank Morrison. Radio interviews, speaking engagements, faculty parties where people actually listened when I talked. And at home..." He trailed off, seeing again Cin's face over breakfast, patient and loving and absolutely unimpressed by his newfound fame. "At home I was still just Frank who forgot to take out the garbage."

no, far too soap-opera, far too on the nose. Also just a bit cliche.

She stood so fast the chair scraped like a scream.

another similie that feels forced. i think you could move away from similes in these moment, She stod so fast the chair screamed.

The House That Remembers: A Wife’s Account of Love and Forgetting

hmm no

disco ball throwing light like shattered glass

these simlies are really starting to stick out like a sore thumb

past houses that looked like wedding cakes and houses that looked like tombs

these sre much better similies that dont draw attention to the device but really build a fresh image.

Coming to the end, this was a great little story really bravo. Where it can be improved really is tighening up your prose. you are already treading along well trodden paths, cheating-writer-husband, dementia-wife, has-been-writer searching for new meaning, the 'story you just read being the story that gets him another deal'. I'm not saying to change of the story but it's how you treat the story that makes or breaks it. Be brutal in the cutting of your similies. Some of the moments you have are also a little too soap-opera - you know which means i mean - but again, this is all in the context of a couple of days writing, this is great foundational work here.
I would say that the theme requirement is maybe a little too loose. What about the location is affecting his psychology here? The location has an affect on the plot, sure, and it has a small link with Cin's memory re: her passage at the end. But this feels more like a theme about memory, not location.

All in all great stuff.

Killing Time in Kansai

great opening, very compelling, and a hint of an interesting voice makes me really want to read on!

to be absolutely ubiquitous and (after only a brief adjustment) completely mundane.

this is a great observation, cutting, and totally believeable in its cynicism.

All I wanted was a change of scene, and to see what there was to be seen.

i like how the theme requirement is being met head on here.

I had probably fewer than 1000 words of Japanese, and many of these were for food items

that's a shit ton of words. dont they say that most people only use a 100 words, and all you need is 100 to get by in another langauge?

however, since Japanese is a highly contextual language.

this sentence is constructed weirdly.

I replied, innocently trying to use as much Japanese as possible, “Hai, douzo!”

refreshing weird and fun.

A good soak alone can cure much dis-ease, i.e., preserve it.

great line, love it

This, despite the enduring popularity of smoking in Japan

another contrast comes to mind, that in japan you can smoke inside but not outside, the opposite of western countries.

“So it’s not sex tourism, it’s masturbation?”

brilliant

You ankles filthy,” she told me.

hahahahhahaha

forgive this extended parenthetical, dear reader, but

this was not needed this break in the (already pleasantly cracked) fourth wall

I understood none of what she sang, but every syllable was true, pure gold

why am i wanting him to fuck this old woman now?

. Of course, Osaka is on the ocean but it is not on the sea in a way that permeates and overcomes its metropolitanism.

im really enjoying this voice. i find very few faults in the prose because it feels so natural and easy to listen to.

Next to Naiku is a preserved medieval shopping street, where I stopped to get Ise udon, the local specialty. These were thick-cut noodles cooked until very soft, and being an al dente guy they were not my favourite.

i will say however, this is beginning to read like travelouge, and while that's not exactly a bad thing, I am a sucker for some drama.

I think the ending comes a bit too abruptly, of course, working to an invisible word count limit is tough - something i fell into with my own writing - but there really could have a been a little more something something to happen, it was place-place-place-then end, again i think to have jazzed with up it would have been AMAZING if Ben had slept with the old lady and then what happened after that would have been so funny to watch and listen to, how would he tell (if he even would) oceane, how would it link to the contrasts mentioned t the beginning etc. just a thought haha.
Also, i do think the 'possessed by lyricism' wasn't really met with any courage. that's one thing cont against this story but I really think this might be my favourite of this months bunch.

atlantic#

Danilo said from the passenger seat, head tilting to the side like an owl that was high as fuck while he scoped the child sitting on a rolling office chair across the street.

a few too many things going on in this sentence. pause for a moment, place us before you tell us everything.

Jose shook his head, gripping the steering wheel firm and playing with the fake platinum chain he liked to wear under his jersey because it felt heavy and thumped against his chest when working. But Danilo already had one leg out the door, Yankee cap pulled low over the top of his face, so Jose only saw the thin bones of his teeth moving as he spoke:

again there seems to be just too much going on.

In the big chunk of paragraph you have, i just feel that every sentence is far too saturated with images. there doesn't seem to be any sort of allowance for an image to sit with me before its gone and replaced by another.

Within 2 minutes a youngster in a black hoodie came by and set up shop, and within another 5 he sold a bag to a couple walking past carrying plastic grocery bags full of chips and pampers

2 men, a couple, bags and things in one sentence

Jose placed the sticky cigar wrapped blunt between his pinky and ring while reworking the fingers around the steering wheel one at a time.

sticky cigar, pinky and ring finger, then fingers again on the steering wheel.

Over and over the lyrics in his head, strong rule the weak, strong rule the weak, strong rule the weak, while the train came screeching back to life and disappeared somewhere to the back of Jose’s eyeballs like a wounded animal clinging to a tree and dying.

an unneeded simile there labours this sentence.

He really was small, all bone, and skin beneath baggy clothing meant to puff up his little frame and make him appear larger.

lazy sentence.

like some demon eye blinking at the far end of a foggy airport.

no

“Damn Jose, I like to fuck pussy, not have it talk, man shut the fuck up.
“Stop playing.”
“Got the opinion of a beaten dog, if I need some whining, I’ll call you up.

great dialogue here

He pulled the car into drive, turned the wheel and pulled out into the street, where his driver’s side window exploded spraying glass over his face like a sudden burst of rain on the soft surface of a lake.

there is just far too much in your sentences. This is a really tough read for me.

The scene of the car crashing just goes so fast, the wounding is barely even considered in the prose.

I'll admit i was expecting a lot more from this story with all the praise in the thread. I found it a real chore to get through. i didnt feel placed anywhere, i felt like this was a story of just words. I didnt see anything happen, really, i didnt feel any textures, i didnt get any sense of place or smell or sound or anything. I also don't think this touches on the theme or character requiremnt at all. big dissapointment.

a short walk

I like how the haiku is incorporated to deal with the character requirement, but it does feel crowbarred in. the writing of the rest of the piece is relatively good, if not a bit bland. some good imagery used such as the overgrowing in the imagination. but really, this was a bit of a nothing story.

djins

this is a real work of imagination and i applaud it! i cant really do line edits for this as it doesnt seem to require it for what it is, but I enjoyed the coming to life of the world around the masturbator, this is almost like a sick toy story or something hahha.

Edit

Pub: 07 Aug 2025 12:06 UTC

Views: 41