Three Parables About Art in the Digital Age
Anonymous
I - The Stone and/or the Statue
“It could've been.”
Going around the large table clockwise, beginning with the geologist who had spoken, one might number the attendees ‘1, 2, 3, 1, 2, 3…’ and thereby observe a curious phenomenon: those assigned ones (geologist included) got constipated sort of looks on their faces at the verdict, the twos seemed to mentally tally up the balance of a ballooning expense, while the threes all found briefings or case law behind which to hide the twinkles in their eyes.
The general contractor, member of the twos, was next to speak, “Well what do you mean it could’ve been? Was it or wasn't it?” He was backed in this by the nodding heads of the land developer and both their attorneys.
“I did what you asked. Samples, studies of the surrounding area, even erosion simulations,” she glanced pointedly at the data scientist, trying to offload some scrutiny, “and I'm sorry to say that it could've been a natural formation. Water, glacial movements, even wind—it's a highly active region, and the limestone in the area is so soft that really any of them could've done it. It's certainly unusual, but so are half the formations around it. I simply can't say for certain that it was man-made. It could've been a naturally occurring formation.”
The materials scientist piped up. “I’d say the chisel marks are proof enough.”
Then second materials scientist, “I'm sure they are for you. But you know they could just as well be the result of eddies, the turbulence in whatever eroded it.”
All eyes turned to the anthropologist. “There's evidence of tribes in the region. The cave was likely used by some of them before it was sealed. They certainly had the tools to do it. Beyond that, we don't have enough evidence about their culture to say.”
The psychologist, or rather, as she insisted on clarifying, professor of psychology, “There have been studies. Now, you all in this room have seen it. You've felt the impact that the statue has on the observer. That's an objective thing. It resonates, it's immediate, and it's evident on the neurological level. Those studies find that art has precisely this effect.”
“That is of course,” the analytical philosopher interjected, “presupposing a definition of art. One which I'm sure we never agreed on.”
The sociologist saw the opportunity and persisted on a line inquisition she'd abandoned earlier “I agree completely. And I think it's absurd to call anything art without knowing the intent behind it. If there’s no intent, there's obviously no meaning.”
The physicist restrained himself from invoking Schrodinger's cat.
They had been going in circles like this for some time. There had been some hope that the geologist, a late arrival, might shed some finality on the matter, but it most had by now resigned themselves to the fact that it was an unsolvable riddle. The land developer was at an impasse with the federal government, the contractor with local government, the investor with all public institutions present and those absent, the art museum with the natural history museum (this pair already being on extremely tense terms which this current issue only exacerbated), and the army of hired experts with the various laws and limits of the natural sciences.
At the end, at a loss of options, they turned to the continental philosopher, “I think there's one party that has remained silent. What do the lawyers have to say?”
II - The Young Aesthete, Von Hussen
In the lingering winter of 1671, Reginald Von Hussen, prince and promised heir to a modest kingdom, was stricken with a terrible illness that laid him up bedridden and feverish. This state persisted. By the time summer came and went, there was little hope. Medicine was still in its infancy, but his physicians were the best in the country. They had seen enough such cases to know that with a fever so high for so long, even a recovery would be a partial thing. Still, eventually, the disease relented and the prince returned. They called it a miracle. To the young Von Hussen, it was anything but. He was left with all his faculties intact; in time he would speak, think, walk, and even ride on horseback as well as he ever had. All his faculties except the one he held most dear.
The young Von Hussen had become, in his seventeen years, a burgeoning patron of the arts. He had traveled to every named state of Europe and the Mediterranean. He had schooled abroad at the finest institutions of the arts. He discovered quickly that he himself had little talent, but that didn't bother him. He had means and taste. He saw the works of all the greatest talents of his time and those before. Moreover, he came to own many of them, and even, in his ever-more-fanciful commissions, arrange to bring them into being. These works adorned his garden, his small sanctuary of cultivated beauty. Before his illness, he would spend most of every morning there, sometimes wandering its trimmed hedges and exotic flowers, around which each lay a work which seeing was like seeing again for the first time, sometimes simply reclining, absorbing anew with awe and reverence his creations, dreaming up new pieces of art to ask of his growing stable of visionaries. The prince did many things, but his art was his one love.
So upon rising from his fevered delirium, it was natural as breathing that the first thing he asked was to be taken to his garden. He missed it and besides he felt it would invigorate him in a way no medicine could. This was when he discovered what he had lost.
The Horse Left to Sea was one particular piece which never failed him. It held a central spot in his garden, so no matter where the young Von Hussen sat, he would always be able to turn, and remember again what art might bring to the world. It was also the first thing one would see upon entering the garden.
So it was that when the convalescent young prince, Reginald Von Hussen, stepped down the final polished stair and stooped his head under the decorous arch that marked the courtyard entrance, his first thought was: Where was The Horse Left to Sea? Yes, something hung there on that far wall. It had certain things in common with the painting he knew so well. Certainly he saw the large swath of blue, the brown shape that might be the titular drowning beast, the careful lines of the unlit lighthouse, yes even the distant ship most failed to spot on first viewing. But where was the listlessness? The slight dizziness of being? The sense of being swallowed up? The wonder at ways the colors played with each other in the roiling belly of both sea and sky? The chill of a November storm? These things all he remembered having felt, but did not feel.
He tore through the garden with abandon, turning every stone. He ogled each statue from every angle, he tried all manner of lighting on the oils and acrylics and even the few regretted watercolors, having servants bring oil lanterns and hold curtains up as shade. When all his art failed him, he tried even, desperately, to sniff some of the white lilies his mother had brought into the garden the summer before last, which sometimes had fleetingly brought him to a wistful mood, but even those were merely perfume. His garden was dead, and to him alone. He didn't need to see anything else to know that whatever it might be called—his sensitivity, his taste, his sensibility—was gone
It was with a despairing heart that the prince first stumbled upon the work of Intolio. It was not long after his sour revelation. He had been walking the streets of the village in venomous spirits, hoping that simple movement might pass the time and return what was stolen from him.
Intolio was a hopeless apprentice to Romero, who himself was the town's foremost man of arts and letters, but who the young Von Hussen had, many years prior dismissed as a rather provincial uninspired waste of paint.
Intolio was displaying his works on the street. He knew his time with Romero was drawing to an end, already the painter was eyeing newer talents out of Venice to foster. Intolio thought perhaps lowering himself to a street vendor for a time might somehow keep his dream alive. If nothing else, he could make good money doing postcards and the occasional portrait for the vain petite-bourgeoisie.
Von Hussen, in his glum mood, almost didn't see the little framed painting in the display. It was hideous, he knew. Every fiber of his artistic learning, told him he was looking at the sloppy uninspired word of an amateur. The perspective was all wrong. The moon was a patchy cliche hanging lumpy over the tops of the buildings. There was no cohesive vision at all. Yet looking at that cityscape, he felt something. He rushed to find the artist. He needn't go far. Before he had made any progress deciphering the illegible scribble of the signature, Intolio came ambling up, bread in hand, wondering at the fact that his art had attracted an admirer, and the notorious snob Von Hussen no less.
It was quick work arranging to take Intolio into his permanent employ. Romero was so shaken at the young Von Hussen’s offering to buy off the apprenticeship that he had accepted a paltry figure. Von Hussen had been prepared to offer much more with little resistance, not wanting to linger in the man's studio, lest he accidentally glimpse one of Romero’s paintings and find himself moved to tears by one of those gauche wall-ornaments.
In the beginning, Intolio worked in the downstairs studio. Soon, it became convenient for him to simply work in the prince’s quarters. It avoided the constant back-and-forth approval that Intolio required to meet the prince's specification. It was quickly apparent that their arrangement would work. It was not hard it all, though he needed to prod the boy into it. He didn't seem to understand what the young Von Hussen meant when he explained the symmetry of the green and the red, the violent brushstroke making him feel uplifted. But all the same, the boy was a quick study. He learned and even began to intuit what the prince might enjoy. The boy seemed to enjoy it on some level. If not the fruits of his labors, then at least the validation he received for them.
Slowly, in this arrangement bore fruit. The young Von Hussen even began to refill his long-since-bare garden with life. He placed the first perfect work of Intolio’s in a small alcove behind the petunias. Some of that something which he had once known was returning to him.
It was two years later that a political necessity called the entire Von Hussen clan to the dreadful place, St. Petersburg for the winter. He loathed to leave Intolio behind, but he knew the boy would be more productive at the estate, and by then he was fully capable of working on his own.
When the prince returned from his winter in Florence, he found garden had been entirely remade in its former glory. Every crevasse was filled with art. And it all moved him. Centerpiece among the wreckage, in the space where once hung The Horse Left to Sea, now sat an abortive mess on canvas, and it looked to Von Hussen like love. A single note was all that remained of the painter.
My dear prince Von Hussen,
I have left this garden for you as a parting gift. I can no longer take pride in making what only baffles me. Whatever muse it is you seek, I hope you find it in the world.
Love,
Intolio
Some one or two decades later, the young Von Hussen grew very ill, and this time he did not recover. He had always been something of a sickly creature. It came as no shock. The elder Von Hussen, who never relinquished his rule to his son, ordered the servants to clear the garden of its atrocities. They were placed in a closet somewhere and quickly forgotten.
III - The Extract
The consul had traveled often to the westward side of the country, but never so far as the town of Errand. The rains were too heavy and seas too near for his liking. His travel was not for leisure, but for an assignment. It was rumored that a pliable official had recently been installed in the Errand government, and the consul intended, at the discreet directive of his supervisor, to investigate.
For most, the extract was a dubious cure-all. For Errand, it was the economy. For the consul and his backing interests, it was the key to a complex web of international trade. It was a byproduct of the distillation of a sort of vinegar. This last was explained to him in hushed tones by the official. He had lived up to his reputation for venality. He confirmed the prevailing rumor of the origin of the extract; it was tied somehow to the hardy berries which grew only in this region. That was where the consul began.
The crops grew in scattered patches along the rocky seaside. There seemed to be no order to it. The hideous turquoise shawl that the consul wore served its purpose admirably and twofold. The heavy wool guarded from the wind, and, just as his informant had promised when he’d given it, the outfit granted him some authority with the townsfolk. He’d had no trouble getting this audience.
“How do you know where to plant them?” the consul asked the pot bellied farmer. The two men overlooked the fields from a rickety metal stairway. They stood about halfway up the embankment. The consul kept a tight grip on the rail.
“Wherever they grow tall. Wherever they make good wine.”
“How do you know where the plants will grow tall? Is there something in the soil you look for?”
The farmer broke a big brambly grin and pointed a finger in the direction of some goats grazing on a far outcropping. “Only that. Where they shit, the berries grow.”
The consul concealed his distaste, trying the other angle, “And how do you know if the wine is good?”
The farmer patted his belly. “I’ve had my fair share. But tell you the truth, I don't know that drinking it ever got me any real taste. And we only drink the second-best, of course.” The consul thought that was it, but the farmer continued. This time in an almost philosophical tone, “If the brewers say it's good wine, then it's good wine.”
The brewery was an open-walled warehouse on the southern edge of the town. It was well-manned and, from what the consul could see, run like a sweatshop. He met with the man who called himself the head brewer.
Before the consul could ask, the head brewer proudly rattled off his pitch, “It is the best wine that we send to the distillery. Only the best. Other places, they make vinegar from the dregs, spoiled batches. But oh no, not in Errand. Not in this brewery. Vinegar first, drinking second.”
“And how do you know which wine is the best?”
The brewer seemed confused. “Whatever makes the finest vinegar.”
Finally he came to the distillery. This, he was assured by his informant, was where the extract itself was produced. It was small compared to the fields and the brewery— just a one-room building. It smelled of cleaning chemicals. The majority of the room, in its sterile tones of white and chrome, was occupied by what seemed to be a menagerie of measuring instruments. A set of large copper vats boiled along one wall. They were tended by a small group of men in long coats. These he assumed must be the distillers.
Despite clearing his throat a few times and making quite sure they saw his shawl, he was forced to approach the distillers. “I am here under the authority of the state.”
The man nearest to him only chuckled and continued his work decanting and mixing. The others seemed not to notice at all.
“I met earlier with the head brewer. He said you tell him which batches of wine to send. Which wine will make the best vinegar.”
The distiller still did not face him. “You heard correctly.”
“And how do you know which vinegar is the best?”
A distiller turned to face him, not the one he'd been speaking to, but a wiry old man at the furthest vat. The man had been busy at a particularly arcane section of the apparatus that had been hissing and spitting a sour steam all the while that the consul had been present. The old distiller didn't say anything at first. He just theatrically twirled a small brown vial in his fingers. “This is what you really want to know about, isn't it?”
The consul weighed his words. “It is,” he began then paused, then began again, deciding frankness was the best approach, “Yes, I wish to know. I don't care how it's made. That’s your business, that's not important—”
The nearer distiller scoffed.
“—I wish only to know how you decide what extract is the best—what extract is effective.”
“What's effective? Who cares what's effective? That's for the testers to say,” the old distiller spat that word, testers, like a familiar vulgarity, “It's the process that matters. This isn't some method passed down by word of mouth; it's not husbandry or farming or brewing or any of the peasant arts. It's science. It's near to perfection as you'll ever see, and most never even sniff it. You get so close to finding the truth—I know what you are and it's under no state authority, not ours at least—-so close to the truth and you don't even want it?”
The consul did not remain for further abuse. He had what he needed.
He waited behind the distillery each morning for four days before he first spotted a turquoise-robed figure enter. He didn't follow him, not that one. He just observed. He was certain that this was the tester. The man spent only a few minutes within before emerging with a small box and departing on foot back the way he'd come. He saw, after the figure left, the younger distiller emerge and toss several cases of vials into a dumpster, looking dejected.
When the next tester came, the consul was ready. The man did exactly as the first had done. This time, the consul trailed him, maintaining a careful distance. The tester walked briskly down the main road. This was a route the consul had become familiar with in his brief time in the town. There was only truly one road in the town, from the distillery to the brewery, north to south. But, just as the man passed the halfway point, he veered off on an unknown course. The consul found himself tailing the man on an overgrown trail through a wooded area. Thankfully, the path was otherwise empty at this early hour and provided plenty of cover to duck behind. Having entirely lost his bearings, it was with surprise, exiting the woods, that the consul found himself on a familiar embankment facing the sea.
The tester entered a barn. Through its cobwebbed window, the consul could see the man carefully remove the dozen or so bottles of the extract he had retrieved from the distillery. He set each on a wooden bench next to its own bucket. One by one, the tester took the dropper from the bottle and put a few drops in its respective bucket. He took the first bucket to a pen. He waited patiently for the goat to eat, then opened the pen to let the animal out into the fields.
This seemed like it would be a tedious process. The consul balanced the value of his time against the likelihood of success. He emerged from the thicket in which he'd been hiding. He held tightly to the grip of the pistol he'd kept concealed in his shawl the entire trip. Moving in quickly, he battered the tester with questions.
The boy in the turquoise shawl turned around slowly, serenely, while the goat released its bowels, and with a gap-toothed smile answered the consul’s questions in a sentence, “Wherever the plants grow tallest, that's the stuff that works.”