Whole House Catalytic Bone Char Carbon Filter Review_10

profile-image

Hi, I'm Ericka F.. I live in Chicago.

Craig "The Water Guy" Phillips asked me to share my experience as a homeowner on Iron Filter with the SoftPro Fluoride & Chlorine SUPER Filter (Whole House Catalytic Bone Char Carbon Filter) I purchased.

This is how my adventures played out. I hope this helps you in your decision.

Did you know that the overwhelming chlorine smell hitting your face when you turn on the shower might be the least of your water quality concerns?

That's exactly what I discovered when my family was distilling multiple gallons of water every single day just to have safe drinking water and keep our houseplants healthy.

Living in Coldwater, Ohio, I quickly learned that our municipal water system pre-softens the town water supply, but this process comes with a hidden cost. The city uses an aggressive chemical treatment to prevent pipe corrosion caused by the salt in the softened water. While this protects the infrastructure, it creates a cocktail of chemicals flowing through our taps.

The chlorine concentration was so intense that you could smell it the moment any faucet opened or the shower turned on. My hair became increasingly frizzy and dry, feeling almost straw-like after every wash. But beyond the immediate discomfort, I was deeply concerned about the long-term health implications, particularly the fluoride content and its potential correlation to cognitive decline and lowered IQ scores that I'd been reading about in various health studies.

The Daily Distillation Routine That Consumed Our Lives

Have you ever calculated how much time and energy goes into distilling several gallons of water every single day?

Our morning routine started with checking our distillation units, refilling them, and planning our day around when the next batch would be ready. We were distilling water not just for drinking, but also for our extensive collection of houseplants that were showing signs of stress from the municipal water.

The distillation process was consuming roughly 2-3 hours of active management daily, plus the electricity costs were adding up significantly. Our kitchen counter space was dominated by multiple distillation units running constantly, creating heat and humidity that made cooking uncomfortable during summer months.

Beyond the inconvenience, I started questioning whether this was even the most effective solution. Distillation removes everything from water - both harmful contaminants and beneficial minerals. I wondered if there was a way to remove the problematic chemicals while preserving the water's natural mineral content.

Researching Whole House Filtration Technologies

My research journey led me deep into the world of water filtration technologies, and I discovered the significant differences between various approaches. Point-of-use filters seemed inadequate for addressing whole-house concerns, while reverse osmosis systems appeared to be overkill for our specific contamination issues.

What caught my attention about catalytic carbon filtration was its targeted approach to chlorine and fluoride removal.

Traditional granular activated carbon filters work well for basic chlorine removal, but they don't address fluoride effectively. Bone char carbon, however, has a unique composition that specifically targets fluoride compounds while maintaining excellent chlorine reduction capabilities.

The catalytic aspect of this filter technology creates a more efficient oxidation process, extending the filter's lifespan while improving its performance against a broader spectrum of contaminants. This meant potentially longer intervals between filter changes and better long-term value compared to standard carbon filters.

The upflow design also intrigued me because it prevents channeling - where water finds the easiest path through the filter media rather than making complete contact. This ensures that every gallon flowing through our home gets proper treatment.

Installation and Initial Setup Experience

The installation process was more straightforward than I had anticipated for a whole-house system. The filter housing arrived with clear mounting instructions and all necessary hardware, though I did opt for professional installation to ensure proper integration with our existing plumbing.

Our plumber was impressed with the build quality of the housing and the simplicity of the bypass valve system. The unit required about 18 inches of clearance for filter changes, which fit perfectly in our utility room next to the water heater.

The initial water flow test revealed no noticeable pressure drop, which had been one of my primary concerns.

During the first few days, I noticed some initial carbon fines in the water, which is completely normal for new carbon filters. The installer had warned me about this and recommended running cold water taps for a few minutes to clear the system.

Programming the system's monitoring features took about 15 minutes, and I appreciated the clear indicators showing filter life remaining and system status. The unit operates silently, unlike some whole-house systems that create noticeable sounds during operation or backwashing.

Immediate Water Quality Improvements

Water Score

The transformation was remarkable and almost immediate. Within 24 hours of installation, the overwhelming chlorine odor that had dominated our bathroom and kitchen completely disappeared.

But the real test came with my hair - would removing the chlorine actually make a difference?

After just three showers with the filtered water, my hair felt noticeably softer and more manageable. The frizzy, dry texture that had plagued me for months began improving dramatically. My hairdresser actually commented on the difference during my next appointment, before I even mentioned the new filtration system.

Our houseplants responded equally well to the filtered water. Plants that had been showing brown leaf tips and slow growth began thriving within the first week. This confirmed that the municipal water chemicals had indeed been causing stress to our indoor garden.

The taste improvement was subtle but definitely present. The slightly metallic, chemical aftertaste that we'd grown accustomed to was gone, replaced by clean, neutral-tasting water that actually encouraged increased consumption.

Performance Testing and Contaminant Removal

Water Score

To verify the system's effectiveness, I invested in a comprehensive water testing kit that measures chlorine, fluoride, and other common contaminants. The results exceeded my expectations and validated our decision to move away from daily distillation.

Pre-filter testing showed our municipal water contained:

Total chlorine: 2.8 ppmFluoride: 0.9 ppmTotal dissolved solids: 320 ppmpH: 7.8

Post-filter testing revealed:

Total chlorine: <0.1 ppm (96% reduction)Fluoride: 0.2 ppm (78% reduction)Total dissolved solids: 315 ppm (beneficial minerals preserved)pH: 7.6 (minimal change)

The fluoride reduction was particularly impressive, considering this was one of my primary health concerns.

What impressed me most was that the system achieved these results while preserving beneficial minerals. Unlike distillation, which creates essentially empty water, this filter maintained the natural mineral content that contributes to both taste and health benefits.

I retested the water after three months of use and found consistent SoftPro Fluoride Filter System performance with no degradation in filtration effectiveness, indicating the filter media was holding up well to our household's water consumption patterns.

Long-Term Cost Analysis and Efficiency

Financially, this whole-house filter has proven to be significantly more economical than our previous distillation routine. The initial system cost was substantial, but the operational expenses tell a compelling story.

Our electricity bills dropped by approximately $35 per month after eliminating the constant distillation process.

The filter cartridge requires replacement every 12-18 months based on our water usage, at a cost considerably lower than the ongoing electricity and maintenance costs of multiple distillation units. Additionally, we've eliminated the need for purchasing distilled water for travel or backup situations.

Beyond direct costs, the time savings are invaluable. No more daily management of distillation units, no more planning around water production schedules, and no more counter space dominated by appliances. The convenience factor alone justifies the investment.

Compared to whole-house reverse osmosis systems that we initially considered, this catalytic carbon approach offers similar contaminant removal for our specific needs at roughly 40% lower initial cost and significantly reduced ongoing maintenance requirements.

Final Assessment and Recommendation

After eight months of daily use, I can confidently say this whole-house catalytic bone char carbon filter has transformed our relationship with our home's water supply. The elimination of chlorine odor and taste, combined with significant fluoride reduction, has addressed every concern that drove us to daily distillation.

Would I make the same choice again knowing what I know now?

Absolutely. The combination of effectiveness, convenience, and long-term value makes this system ideal for families dealing with heavily chlorinated municipal water or fluoride concerns.

This filter excels for households like ours where the primary contaminants are chlorine, fluoride, and basic chemical treatments rather than heavy metals or biological contaminants that might require more aggressive treatment methods.

For families currently distilling water daily, dealing with chlorine-damaged hair and skin, or concerned about fluoride exposure, this represents a comprehensive solution that addresses the problem at its source rather than requiring ongoing management and expense.

The peace of mind knowing that every drop of water in our home - for drinking, cooking, bathing, and plant care - has been properly filtered is worth far more than the system cost. Our daily routine is simpler, our utility bills are lower, and our water quality concerns have been effectively resolved.

Edit

Pub: 19 Feb 2026 17:56 UTC

Views: 5