ALL THIS INFORMATION WAS CAREFULLY INVESTIGATED DURING 12/23/2025 - 12/25/2025
I AM NOT ASSOCIATED WITH THE AFC, UTTP, AXXELET, ANY FPE HATE GROUP, OR ANYONE IN PARTICULAR. I AM SOLO.
Note: While this report covers topics previously mentioned in a community awareness document, all technical evidence (including Twitter API metadata and visual forensic analysis of current social media interactions) was independently verified or discovered by the author of this report.
This document serves as a comprehensive investigative report into the online history, digital footprint, and behavioral patterns of the artist known as Enigmaverse (also known as @circlesaroundu, Edgyaludon, MAG-S, and TheEdgyVerse).
The following findings are based on a synthesis of visual evidence, forensic metadata, and archived social media interactions.
Subject: Enigmaverse (25-year-old Digital Artist), she has verified history of "Rebranding" and fandom manipulation.
- IDENTITY AND ALIAS VERIFICATION
This Investigation linked several disparate identities back to a single individual. The identity trail is established through shared watermarks (like "Agency Torment"), consistent Korean-language doodles, and self-admissions across platforms.


2021-2022 (Madness Combat Fandom): Known as MAG-S and MAG-A-TORTURE. Operated the Reddit account u/NONEIMAGINE.
If you place twitter.com/MAG_A_TORTURE in the Wayback Machine and go to URLs you can see every archived piece of the account VIEW OLD MAG-A-TORTURE POSTS




NONEIMAGINES ACCOUNT DEVIANART
SIMILAR WATERMARKS BETWEEN NONEIMAGINE AND ARCHALUDON


POST IN NONEIMAGINE ACCOUNT:


POST 2


NSFW Identity: Operated the account @NSFWment (also named Masturbate-ment).


NSFW POST, CONTINUE IF YOU ARE 18+
NSFW THREAD
2023-Mid 2025 (FPE Fandom): Rebranded as Edgyaludon and currently Enigmaverse, her Twitter being circlesaroundu.
The twitter account circlesaroundu seems to be deactivated, here is the archive link.
Conclusion: Enigma has a documented pattern of "fandom hopping", she leaves a community once a controversy reaches a breaking point, deleting evidence, and rebranding to attract a new uninformed audience.
- THE DIGITAL FOOTPRINT (FORENSIC EVIDENCE)
The most significant find of this investigation was the extraction of raw Twitter API Metadata (JSON). This evidence moves the claims from "opinion" to "this is technically a fact."
ORIGINAL TWEET https://x.com/Alex99156080/status/1572287184387952640
IF THE TWEET IS GONE, HERE IS PROOF IT EXISTED IN NITTER ARCHIVE.IS:
The Minus8 Interaction: Metadata confirms that on September 20, 2022, the account @NSFWment was part of a thread involving the controversial artist Minus8 (@minuspal) and a Downloader Bot.
How to see this?

CLICK THE INSPECT BUTTON

GO TO NETWORK, CLICK Fetch/XHR, REFRESH PAGE

FILTER OUT “Tweet”

LEFT CLICK ANY OF THESE TWO, CLICK “Open in Source Panel”
Congrats, you have full metadata.
METADATA FOR LAZY:
{
"data": {
"tweetResult": {
"result": {
"__typename": "Tweet",
"rest_id": "1572287184387952640",
"core": {
"user_results": {
"result": {
"__typename": "User",
"id": "VXNlcjoxMTA2MjczNTAwNjQ4NjExODQx",
"rest_id": "1106273500648611841",
"affiliates_highlighted_label": {},
"avatar": {
"image_url": "https://pbs.twimg.com/profile_images/1422194220098535425/cTW72liz_normal.jpg"
},
"core": {
"created_at": "Thu Mar 14 19:18:50 +0000 2019",
"name": "WhiteAlphaKing69",
"screen_name": "Alex99156080"
},
"dm_permissions": {},
"is_blue_verified": false,
"legacy": {
"default_profile": false,
"default_profile_image": false,
"description": "Bwc king\uD83C\uDF46WWO\uD83E\uDD74Join QoH\uD83E\uDD75All woman should serve Superior white men like me\uD83D\uDE08 bow down before your God you beta males\uD83D\uDE0Dall who are not white have shrimp dicks\uD83E\uDD23",
"entities": {
"description": {
"urls": []
},
"url": {
"urls": [
{
"display_url": "Bleachbooru.org",
"expanded_url": "http://Bleachbooru.org",
"url": "https://t.co/iXXA4bOUho",
"indices": [
0,
23
]
}
]
}
},
"fast_followers_count": 0,
"favourites_count": 1915,
"followers_count": 182,
"friends_count": 1877,
"has_custom_timelines": true,
"is_translator": false,
"listed_count": 0,
"media_count": 38,
"normal_followers_count": 182,
"pinned_tweet_ids_str": [],
"possibly_sensitive": true,
"profile_banner_url": "https://pbs.twimg.com/profile_banners/1106273500648611841/1627912551",
"profile_interstitial_type": "",
"statuses_count": 1008,
"translator_type": "none",
"url": "https://t.co/iXXA4bOUho",
"withheld_in_countries": []
},
"location": {
"location": "Your mom's house"
},
"media_permissions": {},
"parody_commentary_fan_label": "None",
"profile_image_shape": "Circle",
"profile_bio": {
"description": "Bwc king\uD83C\uDF46WWO\uD83E\uDD74Join QoH\uD83E\uDD75All woman should serve Superior white men like me\uD83D\uDE08 bow down before your God you beta males\uD83D\uDE0Dall who are not white have shrimp dicks\uD83E\uDD23"
},
"privacy": {
"protected": false
},
"relationship_perspectives": {},
"tipjar_settings": {
"is_enabled": false,
"bandcamp_handle": "",
"bitcoin_handle": "",
"cash_app_handle": "",
"ethereum_handle": "",
"gofundme_handle": "",
"patreon_handle": "",
"pay_pal_handle": "",
"venmo_handle": ""
},
"verification": {
"verified": false
},
"profile_description_language": "en"
}
}
},
"unmention_data": {},
"edit_control": {
"edit_tweet_ids": [
"1572287184387952640"
],
"editable_until_msecs": "1663699251000",
"is_edit_eligible": false,
"edits_remaining": "5"
},
"is_translatable": false,
"views": {
"state": "Enabled"
},
"source": "<a href=\"http://twitter.com/download/android\" rel=\"nofollow\">Twitter for Android</a>",
"grok_analysis_button": true,
"legacy": {
"bookmark_count": 0,
"bookmarked": false,
"created_at": "Tue Sep 20 18:10:51 +0000 2022",
"conversation_id_str": "1530067481175285760",
"display_text_range": [
20,
34
],
"entities": {
"hashtags": [],
"symbols": [],
"timestamps": [],
"urls": [],
"user_mentions": [
{
"id_str": "1758791432662659072",
"name": "minuspal\uD83D\uDD1E",
"screen_name": "minuspal",
"indices": [
0,
9
]
}
]
},
"favorite_count": 0,
"favorited": false,
"full_text": "@minuspal @NSFWment @DownloaderBot",
"is_quote_status": false,
"lang": "qam",
"quote_count": 0,
"reply_count": 0,
"retweet_count": 0,
"retweeted": false,
"user_id_str": "1106273500648611841",
"id_str": "1572287184387952640"
}
}
}
}
}
Enigma knows who the original artist is, is in this tweet on their account, which was deleted shortly after.

Intent: The use of a downloader bot is a "smoking gun." It disproves the "clueless accident" defense, suggesting a deliberate desire to save/archive specific NSFW media involving child-aged characters (e.g., Mandy from Billy & Mandy).
On Twitter, when you see a reply like that, the names listed are the people the user is replying to. Because @NSFWment (Enigma) is in that list, it means Enigma had posted or Quote-Tweeted something, and this other user (WhiteAlphaKing69) was replying to her post to trigger the @DownloaderBot. Since @minuspal (Minus8) is also tagged, it indicates that the media being downloaded was the Minus8 art (the Mandy art).
The logic is that for a bot to be used on Enigma's post, Enigma had to have shared the media first. You don't "accidentally" retweet something that stays up long enough for people to tag downloader bots in the replies. It suggests she didn't just "click a button by mistake", she made the content available on her profile for others to see and save.
https://web.archive.org/web/20221002053401/https://twitter.com/yetaloz/status/1576427301889536005
Scroll down to see the reply
"Non-Con" Engagement: Verified screenshots show Enigmaverse retweeting posts celebrating "non-consensual dynamics" (sexualized rape). Despite the Enigma's claim of a language barrier, the terminology used in these posts was explicit and standard within NSFW subcultures.

- STAFFING AND COMMUNITY RISKS
A critical component of the current "Enigmaverse" brand is the composition of her moderation team and inner circle.
Minor Involvement: Investigation of current staff (2025/24/12, Discord/Social Media) revealed that a 25-year-old adult is employing/directing minors as young as 15 and 17 in a moderation capacity.
SUBJECT 1:


1
SUBJECT 2

IN ENIGMAVERSE DISCORD SERVER
SUBJECT 3

2
SUBJECT 4:

3
SUBJECT 5:

The "DNI" Shield: Current fans and staff use "DNI" (Do Not Interact) lists to block anyone bringing up the creator's past. This creates an echo chamber where the artist’s history is suppressed, young fans are taught to view evidence-based criticism as "harassment."

- TACTICAL MANIPULATION AND DEFAMATION
The Enigmaverse has demonstrated an ability to "counter-attack" critics through a strategy known as DARVO (Deny, Attack, and Reverse Victim and Offender).
The Axxelet Incident: This evidence suggest Enigmaverse utilized potentially faked Discord screenshots to label a 16-year-old minor (Axxelet) as a "predator" to discredit their criticism. Visual analysis of these screenshots showed technical glitches (text alignment and font weight) consistent with manual editing.



The text in the discord image seems to be displaced to the left, here are real Discord Examples:



(I am not defending this guy; this is evidence of the faked screenshots.)
Enigmaverse produces "vigilante" art (e.g., her characters shooting "pedos") to build a social shield. This allows her to signal to new fans that she is "anti-creep," effectively masking her own documented history of engaging with similar taboo content.

- REBRANDING AS A SURVIVAL STRATEGY
Enigma's October 2022 tweet serves as a confession of her methodology:
"I try to win the debate by spreading rumors and making their claims more persuasive by pretending to be my fan."

By her own admission, she uses astroturfing and rumor-mongering to win internet debates. When the reputation of a current alias becomes unsalvageable, she "leaves" the fandom, citing mental health and harassment, only to return weeks later under a new name with the same behavior.

No accountability, Sincere accountability usually involves:
Keeping the original account open to show you aren't hiding.
Clearly addressing the specific actions (e.g., "I shouldn't have downloaded that art").
Educating your audience on why those actions were wrong.
Now, if you go to Web Archive, place https://twitter.com/The_Enigmaverse on the search, go to URLs, go to tweets made in August 29, pop up the search in page (Ctrl + F) and place this number: 1961499256239656979.

You are going to see the interactions between Axxlet and Enigmaverse.

(This whole interaction stops at 1961546232884830248)
Those are the tweets posted chronologically:
When confronted with verifiable digital footprints (such as the metadata or the NSFW history), Enigma consistently frames the evidence as "expired" or "resolved mistakes." This tactic relies on the audience's willingness to prioritize Enigmaverse current "reformed" persona over the technical record.
Enigma's own "proof" against the minor Axxelet shows text-alignment and font-rendering glitches consistent with manual editing, Axxelet points this out, Enigma says back:
"How could two people coincidentally use the same pfp?"
You see, in Discord, It is incredibly easy to change a profile picture in the image editor, and someone could have changed their profile picture to match Axxelet's. It is much harder to fake the alignment and font-rendering glitches that Axxelet pointed out.
Enigma successfully dismissed the initial investigative document by labeling its promoters as "groomers" or "criminals." By making the source of the information socially radioactive, she ensured that her young fanbase would not read the actual data contained within the report.
Enigma (an adult) frequently utilizes her seniority and massive platform to infantilize her critics (minors), telling them they are "not qualified" to speak. This creates a power imbalance where the "popularity" of Enigmaverse outweighs the "facts" of the investigation.
FINAL VERDICT
The artist Enigmaverse is an adult who has successfully navigated fandoms by exploiting the protective nature of young audiences. She relies on the fact that her fans—mostly teenagers—lack the digital literacy to find her deleted metadata or the maturity to see through her performative morality.
The Evidence Confirms:
Intentional engagement with "proship" and "non-con" content.
Deliberate manipulation of her digital trail through rebranding.
Use of minors as a social shield and moderation force.
Weaponized defamation against critics to protect her platform.
This report is intended for awareness only. The patterns identified here are common in predatory online cycles where "clout" is used to shield individuals from accountability.
UPDATE 12/24/2025 1:50 UTC added Link to view old MAG-A-TORTURE posts
UPDATE 12/25/2025 3:35 PM: Added Enigma Interactions with Axxelet
UPDATE 12/26/2025 6:07 PM: On December 25th, 2025, Enigma deactivated her primary Twitter account. In a public statement on YouTube, she dismissed ongoing discussions of her history as "trivial things" and citing a need for mental health and privacy. Enigma admitted to a plan to remain active via a "small, inconspicuous fandom account," while warning fans not to identify her. Enigma continues to utilize her YouTube platform (260k+ subscribers) to maintain her persona while deleting the digital trail of her interactions on Twitter.


















