:notes: /music discovery/

Alt Tag

📌 Written by Dan / FMHY.net :date: Last updated: 13.5.25 :speech_balloon: danxyz7 on Discord


Welcome! This guide explores various avenues for discovering new music beyond mainstream algorithms. We'll focus on curated sources, understanding the landscape, and the sheer joy and reward that comes from active discovery versus passive consumption.

Table of Contents


Music Journalism

Music Journalism is often overlooked, but publications cultivate specific niches and target audiences. Historically, different magazines catered to specific tastes:

Online Publications & Newsletters

Beyond traditional magazines, online sources are key:

Pitchfork
Pitchfork often gets a bad rap, especially with recent absorption into GQ and layoffs, but they undeniably shaped modern online music journalism. Despite challenges, their Best New Music and Best New Reissues sections remain valuable discovery points.

Hearing Things
Hearing Things was started by ex-Pitchfork staff aiming for that early indie spirit.

The Wire
The Wire consistently covers groundbreaking artists years before wider recognition (MF DOOM, Lil B, Moor Mother). Arguably the best source for music far outside the mainstream. Check their Audio section.

The Quietus
The Quietus leans heavily experimental. Excellent for the bleeding edge via their Album of the Week.

Bandcamp Daily
Bandcamp champions the obscure. Bandcamp Daily offers:

  • Features: Deep dives into scenes, artists, genres.
  • Album of the Day: Daily highlights.
  • Lists: Curated discovery treasure troves.
    (More on leveraging Bandcamp itself later!)

Music Newsletters
Many individual critics and curators run excellent, often niche-focused newsletters (e.g., via Substack). Examples include Ted Gioia's The Honest Broker or Shawn Reynaldo's First Floor (electronic). Searching for newsletters in your preferred genres can yield great results.


Influencers & Curators

Video reviews and curated channels offer engaging discovery pathways. It's helpful to understand the type of content creator:

  • Reviewers: Focus on critiquing new releases (e.g., Fantano).
  • Curators/Educators: Explore scenes, history, and connections (e.g., Deep Cuts, Derrick Gee).
  • Genre Specialists: Channels dedicated entirely to specific sounds (metal, folk, ambient, etc.).
  • Historians: Focus on the evolution and context of music.

Key Examples:

Anthony Fantano (The Needle Drop)
Anthony Fantano is polarizing but undeniably influential (NYT: "The Only Music Critic Who Matters (if You’re Under 25)"). He covers a vast range (mainstream, alternative, indie) and has boosted many careers (Death Grips, Charli XCX, Young Fathers). A gateway for many into deeper listening.

Deep Cuts
Deep Cuts explores genres you've likely never encountered. Infrequent uploads, but highly influential (inspiring this guide via this video). Spotify profile: here.

Derrick Gee
Derrick Gee offers interviews (prominent artists), scene spotlights, and art/music commentary. Prefers the term "curator".

A Word of Caution

For every insightful curator, there are many focused on drama over music (e.g., DJ Akademiks types). Be selective; don't let clout-chasing dictate your taste.


Online Communities & Platforms

The internet revolutionized discovery. Early forums and P2P networks (MySpace, Soulseek, even 4chan's /mu/) bypassed traditional gatekeepers, fostering underground scenes and influencing blogs like Pitchfork. Finding genuine, non-commercialized communities is harder now, but dedicated spaces persist.

Key Platforms & Communities

Rate Your Music (RYM)
Rate Your Music is indispensable. User ratings, lists, and charts create a powerful, community-driven discovery engine. Browse the homepage or New Music section for highly-rated releases across countless genres. Excellent for finding consensus classics and current obsessions within niche communities.

Reddit
Subreddits remain valuable, especially for specific genres:

4chan (/mu/)
Use with extreme caution. 4chan's /mu/ board has knowledgeable users but is often toxic and requires sifting through noise. Their historical user-generated "essentials charts" were influential, but quality varies wildly now.

Finding Niche Forums
It's increasingly challenging, but dedicated forums for specific scenes still exist. Persistence pays off. Prioritize finding well-moderated communities.

Other Key Digital Platforms

SoundCloud
Still good, especially for electronic music, hip-hop (demos, leaks), remixes, and DJ mixes unavailable elsewhere. Its "Related Tracks" can be chaotic but sometimes more serendipitous than Spotify's.

Mixcloud
Focuses on long-form audio: DJ sets, radio shows, podcasts. Excellent for hearing tracks in context and discovering curators through their selections.

Bandcamp (Beyond Daily)
Leverage its features for deep discovery:

  • The Feed: Follow other users/fans with similar tastes to see their purchases and recommendations. A powerful social discovery tool.
  • Genre/Location Tags: Explore hyper-specific scenes (e.g., raw black metal Finland, lo-fi house Chicago, psychedelic cumbia Peru). Combine tags for specificity.
  • Label Pages: Follow labels directly to keep up with their entire roster and new releases.

Radio: Curated Streams

Online radio, especially human-curated stations, offers a fantastic alternative to algorithmic playlists.

NTS Radio

Established 2011, NTS Radio is arguably one of the best online music sources globally. Countless shows hosted by artists, DJs, collectors across an unbelievable genre spectrum.

Key NTS Show Formats:

Example Hosts/Shows:

Listening to artists' mixes (like the old Black Midi Variety Hour) reveals their influences directly, like an audio version of Amoeba's "What's In My Bag?".

SomaFM

SomaFM (founded 2000) is listener-funded, largely ad-free online radio. Multiple channels for specific electronic and alternative niches. Favourites include Drone Zone and Groove Salad.

Here are its channels (as of early 2024):

Channel Genre/Theme Year Added
Drone Zone Drone 2000
Groove Salad Downtempo/Chillout 2000
Secret Agent Lounge/Jazz with a 1960s spy theme 2000
Indie Pop Rocks! Indie Pop/Indie Rock 2002
cliqhop idm Intelligent Dance Music 2002
Beat Blender House/Downtempo/Chillout 2002
Boot Liquor Americana 2003
Tag's Trip Classic Trance/Progressive Trance 2004
Xmas in Frisko Eclectic Christmas-themed music (Seasonal) 2005
Space Station Soma Ambient Space Music 2006
Illinois Street Lounge Lounge Music 2006
Doomed Industrial/Dark Ambient 2006
Sonic Universe Avant-garde Jazz 2008
Lush Female-driven Vocal Downtempo 2008
Digitalis Self-produced Indie Rock and Electronic Music 2008
Suburbs of Goa Desi/Arabic-influenced Worldbeat 2008
Underground 80s Early 80s British Synthpop and New Wave 2008
Christmas Lounge Christmas-themed Lounge Music 2008
Mission Control Ambient Music mixed with NASA Mission Broadcasts 2009
PopTron Electropop/Dance-rock 2009
Covers Cover Songs 2009
Black Rock FM Burning Man Festival Broadcast 2010
South by Soma Music by artists from the SXSW Festival 2012
SF 10–33 Ambient Music with San Francisco Public Safety Radio 2012
Dub Step Beyond Dubstep and Bass-driven Electronic Music 2012
Folk Forward Indie Folk, Alternative Folk 2012
Christmas Rocks! Christmas-themed Indie/Alternative Rock 2012
DEF CON Radio Music from DEF CON's Chill Room 2013
Iceland Airwaves Music by artists from the Iceland Airwaves Festival 2013
Deep Space One Deep Ambient Electronic and Space Music 2013
Seven Inch Soul Classic Soul Music 2014
Left Coast 70s Mellow Album-oriented Rock from the 1970s 2015
Fluid Instrumental Hip Hop/Future Soul/Liquid Trap 2015
ThistleRadio Celtic Music 2015
Metal Detector Heavy Metal 2015
Jolly Ol' Soul Christmas-themed Soul Music 2015
SomaFM Live Live Music Broadcasts 2015
Groove Salad Classic Early 2000s Downtempo/Chillout 2019
Department Store Xmas Christmas-themed Beautiful Music 2019
Heavyweight Reggae Reggae, Dub, Ska, and Rocksteady 2020
Vaporwaves Vaporwave 2020
n5MD Radio Music from the n5MD Label 2020
Synphaera Modern Electronic Ambient and Space Music 2021
The In-Sound 1960s & 1970s Euro-Pop 2023
Tiki Time Exotica 2023
Bossa Beyond Bossa Nova & Samba 2023
Chillits Recordings from Chillits Performances 2024

Community & College Radio

Often streamable online, stations like WFMU or KEXP (though KEXP is quite large now) are fiercely independent, championing local scenes and non-mainstream sounds. Explore stations local to you or known for specific genres. Online radio archives can also unearth historical shows and trends.


The Physical Realm: Real-World Discovery

Don't underestimate the power of offline discovery!

Record Stores

More than just shops, they are curated spaces:

  • Browsing Serendipity: Flipping through bins can lead to unexpected finds.
  • Staff Picks & Knowledge: Engage with staff! They are often passionate curators with deep knowledge.
  • In-Store Events & Flyers: Discover local bands, labels, and shows.
  • Used Sections: Unearth forgotten gems, explore related artists cheaply, trace influences.

Live Music

Experiencing music live is crucial:

  • Opening Acts: One of the best ways to find new artists aligned with your tastes, often local or up-and-coming. Pay attention!
  • Venue Curation: Certain venues consistently book specific genres or scenes. Follow their calendars.
  • Niche Festivals: While large festivals can be generic, genre-specific (metal, folk, electronic), experimental, or local festivals are discovery goldmines.
  • Community: Talk to other fans, merch sellers, even musicians at shows. Share recommendations.

Libraries

Often overlooked resources:

  • CD/Vinyl Collections: Can hold surprising depth, including local music.
  • Music Magazines (Archives): Read historical perspectives and discover past scenes.
  • Local Music Archives: Some libraries document regional music history.

Following the Trail: Credits, Collaborators, Samples, and History

Artists rarely exist in isolation. Explore their networks:

  • Guest Features & Collaborations: Check out the solo work of guest artists on tracks you enjoy. Common in hip-hop, R&B, electronic music.
  • Sampling Culture: Use WhoSampled or Samplette to identify original source material in hip-hop, electronic, plunderphonics, etc. This leads back to classic soul, funk, jazz, rock, library music, and more.
  • Producers & Engineers: Note who produced/engineered albums you love (Rick Rubin, Brian Eno, Sylvia Massy, Steve Albini, Madlib, Nigel Godrich). Explore their other work; their signature sound can guide you.
  • Associated Acts & Side Projects: Musicians often have multiple bands or solo projects. Explore the full web of connections.
  • Read the Liner Notes! Physical (or digital booklet) liner notes contain gold:
    • Thank You Lists: Often mention influences, friends' bands, or supportive labels.
    • Detailed Personnel: Discover influential session musicians (drummers, bassists, keyboardists) and check their other work.
    • Recording Info: Studios known for specific scenes or sounds.
  • Use Discogs: While RYM is great for ratings/lists, Discogs is the ultimate database. Explore:
    • Complete Label Discographies: Visually browse a label's entire output.
    • Artist Credits: See everything a specific musician, producer, or engineer has worked on.
    • Versions/Pressings: Find different mixes or bonus tracks.
    • Forums: Niche discussions on collecting and specific releases.
  • Understand Music History: Briefly learning how genres evolve and influence each other (e.g., post-punk's debt to dub and krautrock) provides context and opens pathways to related sounds.

Why Record Labels Have Niches

While major labels (Sony, Universal, Warner) sign broadly, independent labels often reflect a specific curatorial vision. Exploring a label whose key artists you admire is highly effective. Check the label's own website or Bandcamp page for curated stores, news, and direct artist links. Specialized Distributors (like Forced Exposure, Boomkat) can also be discovery points via their curated selections.

Examples of Labels with Strong Identities:


Beyond the Algorithm: The Importance of Curation

Finding trusted tastemakers – whether individuals (Fantano, Derrick Gee, NTS DJs), publications (The Wire, Bandcamp Daily), labels (Kranky, Warp), or even knowledgeable friends – is crucial. Relying solely on algorithms risks homogenizing your taste.

Understanding Algorithmic Limitations (e.g., Spotify, YouTube Music)

Platforms prioritize engagement and retention, often optimizing for passive background listening rather than active, deep discovery. While tools like Spotify's "Fans Also Like," "Related Artists," or Last.fm scrobbling can offer starting points if used actively and critically, they shouldn't be your primary engine. Treat algorithmic suggestions as potential leads to investigate further, not definitive recommendations.

Liz Pelly's book, Mood Machine: The Rise of Spotify and the Costs of a Perfect Playlist, highlights significant concerns:

Note: Anthony Fantano interviewed Liz Pelly about her book here.

  1. Profit Over Artistry: Spotify's model arguably devalues music, prioritizing passive listener acquisition over discovery or fair artist compensation.
  2. Unfair Royalty System: The pro-rata model benefits mega-stars disproportionately, hurting smaller artists.
  3. Homogenization: Algorithmic playlists often favor unobtrusive, "mood-based" music ("Spotifycore"), potentially discouraging diversity and risk-taking.
  4. Pressure on Musicians: Tools like Spotify for Artists can incentivize tailoring music to algorithms, potentially compromising artistic vision.
  5. "Fake Artists" / Stock Music: Playlists sometimes feature generic tracks ("Perfect Fit Content"), reducing transparency and displacing real artists.
  6. AI-Generated Music: Spotify's AI explorations point towards more automated, potentially artist-less, background music.

Context: While Pelly's book was released Jan 2025, concerns existed earlier. Spotify CEO Daniel Ek sold significant stock ($199.7 million) in late 2023/early 2024.


Every Noise vs. Spotify Playlists: Map vs. Filter

What is Every Noise at Once?

Every Noise at Once is (or was) a fascinating algorithmic map of musical genres by Glenn McDonald (ex-Spotify, but not involved in playlisting). It organizes genres by acoustic similarity and data analysis, not popularity or editorial curation.

It functions like a vast sound map where related genres cluster. Explore hyper-specific microgenres, regional scenes, and obscure pathways globally.

Note: Glenn McDonald lost access to Spotify's internal data in 2024. Every Noise no longer receives real-time updates. However, the existing map remains an incredible historical snapshot and structural exploration tool. You can explore the last snapshot of New Music by Genre here.

What Do Intro, Playlist, Pulse, and Edge Mean? (Based on pre-2024 data)

Clicking a genre typically offered these options:

  1. Intro ▶️
    > “What does this genre basically sound like?”
    • Short, raw audio sample of the genre's core sound.
    • Best for: Quick first impressions.
  2. Playlist 🎵
    > “Give me a full playlist of this genre.”
    • Dynamically generated Spotify playlist based purely on the data cluster. Not hand-curated.
    • Best for: Immersing yourself in a specific data-defined sound.
  3. Pulse ❤️ (Historical Data)
    > “What was recently active/trending within this genre?”
    • Used to show songs recently listened to by fans of that genre.
    • Best for: (Historically) Finding what was current in a micro-community.
  4. Edge ⚡
    > “Show me the weirdest/most distinctive tracks at the fringes of this genre.”
    • Outlier tracks stretching the definition—often experimental or hybrid.
    • Best for: Discovering unconventional variations, seeing genre boundaries.

Summary Table (Based on data up to 2024)

Feature What It Does Best For
Intro Short audio sample of the genre's core sound Quick first impressions
Playlist Full Spotify playlist from the data cluster Deep diving into a sound
Pulse (Historically) Trending songs within the scene Finding contemporary buzz
Edge Outlier, experimental songs near the genre edge Discovering unique variations

How Every Noise Differs From Standard Spotify Playlists

Every Noise (Historical) Standard Spotify Playlists
Mapped by acoustic similarity Curated by engagement & branding
Reveals niche, obscure, regional genres Focuses on broad, generic moods
Ignores marketability Optimized for low-skip, passive listening
Built for exploration & understanding Built for retention & background use
Leads to subcultures & diversity Can lead to homogeneity & sameness

The Core Difference: Map vs. Filter

Spotify Playlists often act as Filters:

  • Flatten genre distinctions into moods.
  • Reduce friction for easy, passive listening.
  • Maximize playtime for background consumption.
  • Simplify the music landscape.

Every Noise acts as a Map:

  • Expands and details genre relationships and nuances.
  • Increases friction by presenting complexity and obscurity.
  • Maximizes curiosity and active seeking.
  • Reveals the complexity of the music landscape.

Why This Matters

Standard Spotify playlists frequently collapse distinct genres into vague categories: chill vibes, focus flow, feel good indie, workout beats. This strips away cultural context, regional specificity, and stylistic nuance for mass consumption.

Every Noise, conversely, explodes genre into thousands of specific categories, many rooted in culture or geography: Deep Discofox, German Cloud Rap, Brazilian Death Metal, Vapor Twitch, Scottish Jazz, Italo Body Music. These are sounds you'd likely never find in an official Spotify playlist because they aren't optimized for broad, passive appeal.


In essence: Every Noise revealed the messy, intricate, diverse reality of global music culture. Standard Spotify Playlists often present a smoothed-out, marketable, simplified version. Understanding this difference is key to breaking free from algorithmic bubbles.


Final Thought: True music discovery is an active, rewarding pursuit. Be patient, follow your curiosity down rabbit holes, and engage with human curators – journalists, DJs, record store clerks, fellow fans, librarians, and the artists themselves. As AI automates more, consciously choosing human-centered discovery and supporting artists directly (e.g., via Bandcamp, merch, shows) becomes even more vital for a rich and diverse musical life. Remember the human touch.

For insights into streaming royalties, see this companion guide: Music Streaming Royalties Comparison


If you feel that there are errors (or you just want to give general feedback), please feel free to reach out. 💬Discord: danxyz7

Edit Report
Pub: 01 Apr 2025 14:27 UTC
Edit: 12 May 2025 23:37 UTC
Views: 2365
Auto Theme: Dark