Based on a full viewing of the music video and an analysis of its narrative, the negative receptions in the 4chan comments are not on point. They are based on cynical assumptions, a misunderstanding of common tropes, and, in one user's own admission, a failure to watch the video properly.

Here is a breakdown of the video's story and why the comments are misguided.

The Actual Narrative of the Music Video

The video tells a complete story about nostalgia, loss, and reunion, spanning over a decade.

  1. The Present (Melancholy): An adult woman, seemingly on her 29th birthday, is alone in her apartment. She lights candles on a single slice of cake, looking sad and lonely. This sets up a theme of longing for the past.
  2. The Past (Youthful Love): The video flashes back to her high school days. She had an incredibly close, and clearly romantic, relationship with another girl. They share intimate moments: reading a book together ("アンナの土星" or "Anna's Saturn"), sharing food, running freely, and the other girl playfully making a "ring" for her out of a four-leaf clover. This period is depicted as vibrant, happy, and full of life.
  3. The Separation: There are hints of sadness and an eventual separation. The main character is shown crying and alone in her old room, implying her friend/lover left or they drifted apart.
  4. The Present (Reconnection with Self): The adult woman finds a box of mementos from her youth, including the book and the dried clover ring. This triggers a powerful emotional response. She begins running through the city at night, as if chasing her memories. In a symbolic sequence, her adult self meets her younger self, and they run together, signifying a reconnection with the feelings of her youth.
  5. The Climax (Reunion): The final scene shows the adult woman meeting her friend, also now an adult. The friend holds out a new, fresh clover ring. They look at each other with tears in their eyes and smile. This is a happy, tearful reunion after years of being apart.

Addressing the Negative Comments

Let's break down each comment:

"Great, more lesbian torture porn. Just what I needed."

  • Why it's wrong: This user is jumping to a conclusion based on the "Bury Your Gays" trope, where LGBTQ+ stories are expected to end in tragedy. The video starts with melancholy and depicts the pain of separation, but its entire point is the subversion of that tragedy. The ending is hopeful and confirms their bond endured. It's a story of reunion, not "torture."

"not even a minute in I already knew it's gonna be some S class bullshit"

  • Why it's wrong: This is a purely cynical, low-effort dismissal. The user made up their mind instantly, likely upon seeing the yuri themes, without any intention of engaging with the story. The video has a clear narrative arc, strong emotional weight, and high production value. Calling it "bullshit" is a reflection of the user's prejudice, not the quality of the video.

"I skipped directly to the final 30 seconds. Is one of the girls dead or something?"

  • This is the most telling comment. The user admits they did not watch the video. They skipped to the emotionally charged reunion, saw the tears, and immediately assumed the worst-case scenario (death, ghosts, etc.).
  • Why it's wrong: Their interpretation is factually incorrect precisely because they lacked the context of the full story. The tears are tears of joy and relief at seeing a long-lost loved one again. Both characters are alive and have found each other.

Conclusion

The 4chan comments are a perfect example of cynical, knee-jerk reactions that fail to engage with the art itself. The users saw a story about two women, assumed it would follow a negative trope, and either dismissed it outright or misinterpreted the ending to fit their preconceived notions.

The music video for "Ever" is not a tragedy. It's a poignant and ultimately uplifting story about a love that withstands time and distance, culminating in a beautiful reunion. The negative receptions are, therefore, completely off the mark.

Edit

Pub: 16 Jul 2025 13:07 UTC

Views: 11